So recently I wanted to get into the series again, got game 5 from the torrent in the OP, and it crashes whenever I interact with another window. I'm on the same toaster I was back then, in fact I never removed the games, they're still in the same place and working fine. The weird part for me is that I played through the first four games years ago, and they never crashed. Well, Sono Hana New Gene has (hopefully) its own merits. Sono Hana is just a veeery different series, so that kind of impact is rather impossible. Though I don't expect it to be on a level like the true route of Resonance. It's like they run out of time and tried to finish the route in some half-assed way. Yuu's route in Resonance is awesome, until the final part just randomly happens. Some weaknesses can also be not the fault of the author. Haven't seen anything of Madoka in Sono Hana, but I think in theory there is a lot of potential to be had. The first has literally a girl as a heroine, who tries to kill the MC several times and is REALLY NOT NICE, while the latter has a girl who's a major bitch to the MC and certain other people. This is true for both Resonance and Shirokoi. Well, also let's not forget how Madoka can make some raaaather unlikeable heroines. And while a "main-story" is teased, nothing really happens there either. Sometimes you'd get a "scolding scene", where the reason the scolding happens is told via narration in three lines before. But after the first chapter, it just became a mess of disconnected scenes. It was pretty well done, as the mistakes and whatnot the MC did were all rather believable. The first chapter was able to give a nice introduction to the whole nurse thing. On the other hand you have Shirokoi, which after the first (really well done) chapter simmers off and just becomes boring. It also didn't really drag on or anything. The true route of Resonance was almost perfect. Madoka can actually write something really good. This is why I want to see her write one couple in a big game in order to verify whether her "uncompelling plot" trait is just due to screentime constraint, or actually due to inability. I have noticed her writing progression from Shirokoi to the nurse games and now to NewGene, and it's getting less and less anime-ish. Her dialogues read like something one would actually say in real life (particularly the banters between friends). Her characters are usually multi-dimenional and feel like real people with beliveable quirks. Madoka, on the other hand, always leans more towards mainstream novel writing. His style is frankly very anime-ish and stereotype-reliant. This is not to say Jun is untalented, just that he's still more or less generic in proses/dialogues/characterization. Its primary brilliance lies in Miya x Risa chemistry instead of a notable writing talent. However, Shirayuki was subpar (literally just a bit better than Sano's stuff), which led me to believe that Otome was just a lucky stroke. Like I said before, I immensely enjoyed Otome-tachi. The conclusion of who writes better is thus just what one personally enjoys more. Tl dr: Hazuki is the girl any heir/heiress would realistically wish for in a partner.įrom your post, I have the feeling that we actually have the same assessment for Madoka vs Jun writing. All I could think was "This kid is gonna grow up into a cunning yet good-hearted woman. I was honestly stunt by the way she handled Manami after the Christmas party. Hazuki is an extremely balanced person, neither too idealistic nor too cynical, kind yet not a pushover, positive yet practical, clever and mature. I initially thought Hazuki is just another Nanami/Risa rehash (silly girl who likes to fantasize, has some redeeming qualities such as hard working and not totally stupid), but man oh man, I was wrong. Madoka = characters development to build up drama and tension. The last act of Hazuki x Manami route feels abrupt and feels surreal.The entire build up feels dragged and the climax just seems too spontaneous and rushed.īoth have their pros and cons. >superior characterization/character dynamic There are times those lines sounds kinda forced to me. This is my opinion, it would not matter to anyone anyway: Madoka Madoka is better at developing her characters but Jun is skilled at tackling the franchise as a whole. Yes, she is well versed in dramatic twist and character development in a self contained story but she is pretty bad in making a compelling story entirely. I, however still dislike Madoka Madoka's writing because throughout the entire nurse series and Newgene, she still has that tendency to drags out her story and that what makes her stuff annoyingly bored. That is your opinion and I totally respect that. Note: Translations are currently offline, probably due to above You can buy it here and get an steam key: 2013265Ī Kiss For The Petals - Remembering How We Met released: Sono Hanabira / A kiss for the petals Anonymous 14:39:42 Post No.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |